October 23, 2009 · Behavior | Influences | School
Is pretend violence okay?
Girl Child at the mirror, grooming for school. She vamps for full effect.
Little soon for that, but, hey, she does her own hair now. Brushing I do not miss, like branding a calf that screeches about pain and mommy doing it right.
But then she says to the mirror, all sly and flirty face, “Today I’m really going to get Garrick …”
“Get him how?”
“Lock him in jail and kill him.”
Thank God, still age appropriate. But also a sign that we as a species are doomed.
Garrick dies today because he leads Boys Team in Boys Team Against Girls Team. They’re at it again, just like last year.
BTAGT is major recess-time entertainment at Big Brick Elementary School. To grown up eyes, it looks like any old chase game. But we hear about magic keys, code words, objects that confer special powers. Kids switch sides, with certain “girly boys” (GC’s words) choosing GT for, you know, inner sync.
Metrosexual Harry Potter, how cool and Unsuburb is this?
However — at least in our house — the thing gets Afghan Insurgency. Since last year GC has done home arts-and-crafts weapons, like a painted rock/laser, another rock treated (Webkinz-brand mango spray scent) to repel the enemy, and a thing causing uncontrollable crying.
The stuff, especially hand-beaded secret electronic jewelry, is tres arty and Waldorf School. GC also labors over special ops. My fave remains the plot to incapacitate Boys Team Leader with a door boobytrapped to explode and shoot rocks. Poor guy then gets strapped into a chair that centrifuges him until he gives up his side’s key.
New developments: First Grader writing and numbering on e-devices. GC uses construction paper to make battle laptops that, among other things, direct remote surveillance (flying drones, I think), and she does phones for secure communications and apps.
“Oh yeah, I push this button and a bomb explodes right by Garrick.”
Yow. Pater, who is borderline pacifist — we go to the Quaker Meeting, for Christ’s sake — wonders if concern should be expressed.
I happen to believe that our worst global horrors were caused by arrested development suits playing pretend war with actual uniformed U.S. Armed Forces.
Do we stop the cycle here?
Also, on a psychotherapeutic note, What if that if this heinous stuff is all in our child’s head?
Mom and I think maybe, but there’s no good way to confirm — Dave, Violet, we were wondering if Missy has a make-believe weapons lab and, um, talks about remotely detonated IEDs and torturing other kids …
Nah.
Let it go. She’s six. She knows it’s wrong to hurt people. At least she says so, angelic and convincing.
You tell me, is pretend violence okay?
Simon dead-on nails fathering a little girl. Chasing away bad dreams, standing guard as she goes back to sleep, loving everything that’s coming — “I’m gonna watch you shine/Gonna watch you grow.” Could be schlurpy, but just right.
Be a lumberjack and be okay, ecoweenie-wise. Little dude (8-inch bar) cuts better than you’d think, with no emissions ‘cause it’s powered by…
July 15, 2010 | Permanent Link
Comments
It matters not if it’s okay, since you can do nothing to stop it. No, I take that back: you can do something. End real violence in the world, so children have no examples of violence to emulate. Or maybe I’m wrong. Maybe it’s a “chicken and the egg” thing. Which came first, “real” or “pretend” violence?
Comment #1, posted by Ellen on October 24, 2009 at 06:03:09 PM
Your Girl Child sounds brilliant, competitive, analytical and cunning. My only concern is if you hear her mumbling something about pater elimination. It’s okay to wipe out the playground but not Daddy. Warning: If she hears the music on this site you may have a rock/laser/poison/grenade/bomb in your honeynut cheerios.
P.S. Love your site. So Latin. Are you a pharmacist?
Comment #2, posted by Debbie on October 25, 2009 at 08:39:07 PM
Yo Pater,
send GC down the street for some Three Stooges… We teach kids how to smack people in the face the old-fashioned way in our family.
Hey, it’s homo homini lupus, Hobbes and all, state of nature, so what is Pater going to do about it? Someone once told me all children are criminals and it is our job to civilize them.
Not sure I agree but I do think we have our work cut out for us…
Mater Familias
Comment #3, posted by Mater Familias on October 25, 2009 at 10:44:46 PM
I’m struck by the detail GC provides in sharing details of her day. I seem to be on a Need to Know basis with both children. Plus neither kid (8 & 11) seem to retain memory of/interest in anything 5 seconds after it ends. I’ll ask about a play we saw the night before and get puzzled glances—why are you asking about something that is so, so…last night?—they seem to be wondering. Otherwise, I share your pain on the violence question and have grappled with it myself.
Comment #4, posted by Melody on October 26, 2009 at 11:29:26 AM
Four First Mamas, thank you for commenting. Individual comebacks from Pater…
1) Ellen—Unanswerable, so I won’t think about it.
2) Debbie—Not a pharmacist, only a really good customer.
3) Mater—Finally, Thomas Hobbes and Latin. I was about to give up.
4) Melody—Yes, but look what she remembers.
P
Comment #5, posted by Pater on October 26, 2009 at 11:48:11 AM
Post a Comment